song choice, song choice, song choice

Song choice has surely become the judges' favorite reason to criticize the idol wannabes. I don't really remember it ever being such a popular excuse before this season, but anyways, about last night:

Lisa - as much as i like this chick, she is totally going home very very soon because she sounded very not good. i mean seriously, please don't butcher Kelly Clarkson. It's not cool.
Kellie - cute little country girl, ain't she? I think she might want to stop playing dumb soon though.
Ace - okay, i do realize that america swoons over this guy, but come ON. I'm so done with him.
Taylor - he sounds like he's singing the exact same song every single week.
Mandisa - what a very, very strange song choice.
Chris - woah. that was some hardcore rockin' out. almost scary. settle down chris. i like you too much to let America send you away, and they just might do it if you continue being so scary.
Katharine - oof. that song didn't do it for me, though people seemed to enjoy it. she's lucky she's a hottie, although seriously, what the hell was that outfit?
Bucky - very underwhelming. and along with Paul and Simon, I couldn't understand a word he was singing.
Paris - she is not seriously only 17...is she?!
Elliott - not bad, not bad at all. a nice, solid, normal performance. its a voters delight.

i can't even guess who might go home tonite, there was so much awfulness. maybe Lisa. or Ace. or Bucky. I'd be fine with any one of those.